Best Shingle Remover For The Money

Best Shingle Remover For The Money

Publushed by:

James

Last updated:

If your roof shingles have been damaged, such as from water, you will have to replace them.

Removing and replacing your roof shingles extends your roof’s lifespan, so it’s worth doing, but to DIY this roofing project you need to purchase a tool known as a shingle remover.

What is a shingle remover?

This is a tool that has teeth at the end to help you remove roof shingles. It usually has other important design features to make replacing shingles a much easier task, such as being able to remove shingle nails at the same time as shingles.

With that in mind, let’s explore the best shingle remover tools on the market. We’ll start with the number-one tool one you should own if you have to do roofing repairs.

Best Overall: Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Short summary

This shingle stripper comes in a pack of four and it not only removes the shingles from your roof but also their nails, all in one easy motion. This is thanks to how the shingle remover is built with a wedge design.

The idea of removing roof shingles can be a daunting one, which is why this best shingle remover aims to make it as fuss-free as possible. This shingle strippper has a long handle that makes it easier to hold and control when you’re reaching up to remove roof shingles.

It also has a serrated edge on the bottom. This is strong and if it breaks you can buy replacement blades, which makes this a tool that will serve you well for several years. 

The tempered steel and robotic welds of this shingle remover boost its durability and strength. By having this tool in your possession, you can prevent damage to your roof and that also helps to reduce how much time you need to dedicate to cleaning up after your work is done.

This tool can be used to successfully remove shingles from multi-layered and plank roofs. Since it’s user-friendly and convenient, it will help you to spend less time on roofing repairs.

Quick Facts

Pros

Cons

Best Shingle Remover

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Runner Up: Guardian 54-Inch Shingle Removal Shovel

Short summary

If you’re a professional roofer or you have a lot of work to do on your roof, you’ll be glad to know that this roof shingle remover is built ergonomically to reduce fatigue. It’s also equipped to pull up to 16D nails so it’s ready for the toughest tasks.

With 54 inches of length, this shingle remover tool is ideal for giving you greater leverage when removing roof shingles. It’s therefore a valuable tool to use when you need to get to hard-to-reach spots on your roof.

What’s great about this shingle remover is that it has an angled design, which helps you to feel more comfortable when using it. You won’t have to bend over, therefore preventing back aches and pains.

This slightly curved shingle remover has a rugged, all-steel construction to make it strong and tough. However, it’s lightweight to hold. If you need a shorter shingle remover, you can purchase this Guardian tool in 22.5 inches instead.

With its tough and durable design, this best shingle remover is ideal for removing shingles from pitched roofs. It can be used on asphalt and fiberglass shingles.

Quick Facts

Pros

Cons

Best Shingle Remover

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Best for Budget: Malco The Beast Roof Shingle Removal Tool

Short summary

What sets apart this remover from other types of shingle removers on the market is that it has an adjustable head – this not only makes it easier to manoeuvre but it also accommodates a variety of roof pitches.

This shingle remover is designed to make it easier for you to strip roof shingles without having to call the roofing professionals. It cleanly lifts heavy shingle loads and pulls out their nails, all in one motion.

It’s good to consider that its adjustable head will help you to work more comfortably, thereby preventing back aches and pains during long hours of shingle removal.

Another example of its user-friendliness is its handle, which is made out of heavy-duty fiberglass. This is both lightweight to carry and it offers greater balance as well as control. The shingle remover comes with tempered steel blades, and these are replaceable, which increases its lifespan.

For even greater ease of use and comfort, this shingle remover can be purchased with either an adjustable head or a fixed head if this is more comfortable for you when you need to remove asphalt shingles.

Quick Facts

Pros

Cons

Best Shingle Remover

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Alterantive: Bon Tool 19-115 Roofer's Tear Off Spade

Short summary

These remover work well to grip and remove nails with ease. This tool has a heavy-duty fixed design, which gives you more leverage when you’re up on the roof so you don’t have to waste a lot of time removing shingles.

If you’re battling to remove shingle nails during your roofing project, this tool will come to your rescue. This best shingle remover is actually a spade that’s ideal for tearing off shingles because of how it’s been built with serrated teeth.

This shingle remover has been designed to be strong and withstand a variety of conditions, so you don’t have to worry about it giving up on you or becoming damaged easily. It has an ample blade size that’s 10 ½ inches by 6 ⅞ inches, which makes it easy to remove shingles without having to do multiple passes on the roof. This also ensures that you reduce the risk of damaging your roofing material during the process.

The length of this shingle remover tool also makes a difference in increasing its user-friendliness. With a length of 48 inches, this roof shingle remover gives you a lot of leverage and helps you to reach all areas of your roof with greater ease so you don’t have to spend all day working on your roof.

Quick Facts

Pros

Cons

Best Shingle Remover

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Alterantive: Shingle Eater 6127

Short summary

Shingle Eater is a brand that’s been producing quality roofing tools to make your roofing repairs easier since 1981, and the tools are made in the USA. Their Shingle Eater 6127 tool is built with lots of features to make removing shingles from your roof a DIY possibility.

This best shingle remover tool is lightweight, as it’s made of carbon steel, so it’s easy to handle and this will make you feel more in control when removing shingles. That said, it’s still rugged enough to get the job done quickly.

It’s been built with a variety of features to make it strong and user-friendly. It’s got a foot plate that’s been flame-hardened as well as heat-tempered. This makes it durable.

It also has a base plate which features stiffening corrugations. It comes with a 46.5-inch handle that’s long enough to give you enough leverage, and 10 teeth for gripping shingles.

With features such as the above, this tool is built to last. It’s also versatile as it’s not limited to removing roof shingles. For example, some people who have purchased this tool have said that it works well to remove hardwood flooring. This tool is going to be a versatile one that every DIY homeowner should have in their toolbox.

Quick Facts

Pros

Cons

Best Shingle Remover FAQ

Now that we’ve featured some of the best shingle removal tools, you might want to know if it’s worth your time and money to purchase one.

Let’s explore some information you should know about shingle removal, such as if you can DIY your roofing repairs or you should call the professional roofers instead. 

Can I remove shingles myself?

You certainly can remove roof shingles yourself as long as you feel comfortable with the DIY task. This could save you lots of money because you won’t have to call the professionals.

However, there are some tips you should follow. Here’s a rundown of them. 

  • You should start at the roof peak and use your tool, such as shingle remover, to pry off the shingles from the ridge cap. 
  • Then, slide the tool underneath the shingles and lift the tool straight up so that you can release the shingles.  
  • You should continue working in sections of the roof that are about 2-3 feet. This makes the task more manageable. 
  • Remove the shingles as you work so that cleanup will be easier. 
  • When you get to structures in the roof such as your chimney or flashing, be extra careful. Around such structures you should try to pull loosened shingles by hand to prevent damaging them. 

What is the best tool to remove shingles?

You can use a variety of tools to remove shingles. For example, some people say that you can use a garden fork.

However, to ensure that you prevent damaging your roof shingles, you should invest in a shingle removal tool. These are best to preserve your roof and they make it easier for you to remove shingles and their nails in one go.

Based on our reviews, the best tool to remove roof shingles is the shingle stripper by MBI tools. This removes the nails and shingles from your roof in one motion. Since the shingle remover has a wedge design, it makes it easy for you to remove shingles without a problem.

As a bonus, it also has a long handle. This makes it user-friendly and comfortable to control when you need to reach higher up on the roof to remove shingles.

Should you remove the plastic strip on shingles?

When you want to install new roof shingles, such as those made of asphalt, you might have noticed that the shingles have cellophane strips on them.

What are these? To ensure that the wind won’t catch the loose end of the shingle tab, this adhesive on top of the shingle lines up with the loose end of the shingle that’s placed above it. The sun heats it up and makes the shingles stick together after they’ve been placed on the roof. To prevent them from getting stuck together when the shingles are still in the package, a protective strip is used.

Do you have to remove them? Although these strips used to have to be removed, manufacturers changed them by making them out of a special polyethylene film. This dissolves after being exposed to the sun after some time and therefore you don’t have to remove it.

In case you’re wondering, the plastic has no effect on how the asphalt shingles will perform. You can leave them as they are. If you feel you have to remove the plastic, such as because they irritate you, remember that it’s unnecessary to do so and just gives you an extra step to follow during your roofing repairs, which is a waste of time. 

Is it better to remove old shingles?

Although you can place new shingles over your existing roof shingles, which can decrease your installation costs, you need to ensure that you install the shingles properly otherwise they won’t lie flat. 

There are some good reasons why you should put new shingles on old shingles, such as that the process is less expensive, easier, and less time-consuming than stripping your existing shingles. This process is known as reroofing.

However, it’s important to avoid putting new shingles over existing ones in some cases, such as the following:

  • You already have two layers of shingles on your roof. It’s important to bear in mind that most building codes allow only two layers of roofing materials to be installed in your home. After that, you will therefore have to tear off the roof and install a new one.
  • Your existing shingles are curling. Or, they’re in otherwise bad shape, such as that they’re showing signs of damage. This is counterproductive to installing shingles because the new shingle roof has to be able to lie flat on the old one. If your shingles are damaged or curling, this will prevent you from getting a flat, straight result so it’s best to avoid attempting this.
  • Your roof has leaks. If your roof is in bad shape, such as that it leaks whenever it rains, you have to ensure you repair your roof before you try to install new shingles. Otherwise, you’ll have a roof that looks new but it’s still suffering from the same problems.
  • Your roof is spongy. When you climb onto your roof and walk around on it, does it feel spongy or soft underfoot? This is a sign that you have a problem with the roof’s underlying sheathing, and this will have to be repaired by first removing the existing roof before you can install new shingles.
  • Your roof won’t tolerate the additional weight. Roof shingles can be heavy. While individual shingles might not feel heavy when you carry them up to the roof and install them, when they are installed on the roof their combined weight will be very heavy, so you have to ensure that your roof’s structure is strong enough to handle the extra weight. A professional inspection can help you to find out if your roof is strong enough. 

Conclusion

If you want to remove shingles on your roof yourself instead of having to call the roofing pros, you need to purchase the best shingle remover. There are many different tools on the market, and this can make it difficult to know which one to buy.

After reading this guide, though, you now have a better idea of the best shingle remover tools that are worth your time and money, as well as what features you should look for when shopping for a tool to help you renovate your roof.

We’ve also looked at information to help you DIY the removal of your roof shingles so that your roof looks better, remains in excellent condition, and boosts the overall appearance of your home.

Removing damaged, old shingles and replacing them with new ones will strengthen your roof against the elements and ensure your house has better stability, so it’s something you should consider if your roof is looking old.

Reference Articles:

BEST OVERALL

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

Size: 47 inches
Handle: Plastic
Material: Metal

Best Shingle Remover

4.5/5

Shingle Stripper by MBI Tools

James

James Weldon is a professional roofing contractor with many years of experience on the job. He does not only handle large projects and provide excellent services for his company’s many clients; James Weldon also dedicates his spare time to teaching others useful tricks of the trade. Using BuildCampus as an avenue to reach many roofers and aspiring roofing contractors, James Weldon continues to provide high-quality educational posts and buying recommendations for anyone who visits the website.